Skip to main content

Thank you Mr. Neely, but why do I feel like I am doing the time warp again?

       The headline came across the webpage for our local, alternative, news weekly like something from two decades ago. It was written by renowned, local author/historian Jack Neely. It made me feel like the case was already well known by the greater Knoxville community: "The Case for Saving Two Downtown Buildings." I'm sorry, what? Did I accidentally jump into my DeLorean and travel back to 1992 (astute readers will remember this as the year the Mann Funeral Home was destroyed)? How in the world could this headline exist on October 18, 2011? It was as if no historic buildings had been repurposed, as if no one lived in the Holston, as if the fundamental values of reusing and maintaining the structures of our past had never been embraced. It was like Knox Heritage never existed and Mary Temple Boyce was still fighting to keep Blount Mansion from becoming a pile of rubble. I could not believe my eyes, yet here we were again. Another entity, one with a history of tearing down beautiful old buildings (Mann's again, anyone?) was poised to pluck two more buildings from the landscape of downtown.
       The justification for such a travesty seemed like it was straight out of that 1992 playbook: the buildings were ugly, far beyond saving, we need some open space. I began thinking of all the examples of this senseless process: the Sprankle Flats, the J. Allen Smith home, and almost the entire Terrace Court neighborhood being recent ones. If one were to take a walk around Knoxville today, one would see some great, remaining structures, but there also existed in Knoxville buildings that if you described them to any teenager on Market Square today, they would accuse you of telling fairy tales. Sure, the Whittle...err...Federal Courthouse is grand but do you remember the Vendome? You don't? Well, it was pretty impressive, once billed as the most impressive building in Tennessee. Still evidently, it wasn't more impressive than a surface parking lot on Clinch Ave. Parking lots have their place, of course, but no one puts parking lots on post cards, "Oh here's the budget pay lot in Schenectady, how quaint."
      What is the meaning of all of this rambling and why put it in a blog, you may ask. I would respond that while I don't want the tone of my blog to be overly negative or combative, I would like to document for the people of this city some of what has been lost over the years due to misguided notions of "progress." I hope to educate, inform, and hopefully ignite in the community a yearning to preserve what is left of the past for future generations. I never saw the Vendome, it was  long gone before I arrived on this planet, but I have no doubt that it would have been the crown jewel in a vibrant downtown Knoxville.
       As of the writing of this entry, we don't yet know the fate of the two buildings on Walnut St., but their current predicament has energized me to get this blog off the ground. The nature of such a blog will likely mean delays between substantive posts (what with research, photo permissions, etc.) so I will likely post progress reports, chit chat, what have you in the intervals. With that all said, let's go find some Knoxville lost.

Comments

Melanie said…
I'm here! And now I am inspired to go find out what the heck the Vendome was......
Anonymous said…
I agree with what this author has posted. Leave our buildings of past that we should embrace, refinish, but not destroy. Progress for the sake of progress is idiot backed nonsense.

Popular posts from this blog

322 S. Gay St. - The Terminal Building - The Gaps of Gay Street Part 1

If you have lived in Knoxville for any length of time, or if you've just eaten at the Downtown Grill and Brewery, then you have without a doubt heard of the "Million Dollar Fire of 1897." That fire destroyed much of the east side of the 300 and 400 blocks of Gay Street. Firefighters came from as far away as Chattanooga to battle the blaze, which threatened to burn down the entire city. With the ruins smoldering, city leaders declared it the greatest loss the city had ever suffered. However, times were optimistic and the business community vowed the next day to rebuild the structures better than before. Most of them were rebuilt, bigger and better, within five years. Fighting the fire of 1897. To the right, the Cowan McClung & Co. (now H.T. Hackney and The Market). Almost everything decimated. (Century Building at left, still standing)   From the ashes of the fire, rose many of the iconic structures we see today on the 300 and 400 blocks. Identifying them b

5709 Lyons View Pike - Westcliff

There has been a lot of discussion in the local property blogs about the proposal of a new shopping development located at the intersection of Cumberland Ave. and Alcoa Hwy. Anyone who has played or follows rugby in Knoxville knows this place very well. It's called Fulton bottoms and the reason it is called Fulton bottoms is that just across third creek was once the principal factory of the Fulton Company.  The Fulton Bellows factory as it appeared in the 1930's. This is looking from the Southeast. Note the train tracks which still exist and Cumberland Ave./Kingston Pk. looking very rural. Most of the background in this picture is taken up by the Alcoa Hwy/Kingston Pike interchange.  Roughly the same view today. The factory is gone. The foundation pads are all that remain. The story of the Fulton Co. is an interesting but long one. It's probably a subject for another entry, however if you'd like to read the whole story you can find it here , as told by Ja

333 W. Depot Street (Regas Square) - The Atkin Hotel

Checking the local newspaper today, I found an article focused on plans to build a bullet train from Savannah, GA to Chattanooga. High speed rail is touted as the transportation solution of the future. The rail system in Europe functions as the backbone of transportation on that continent. I understand that it is very important in Asia as well. There was a time when rail was the precursor for development in the United States. A grand majority of towns in the interior US were built with their faces turned toward the shiny rails that brought the big steam locomotives. Knoxville, though founded well before train travel, was much affected by the rise and importance of the railroad. Knoxville, being a larger city, had two major railroad stations, the L&N and the Southern. The L&N, located in what is now the World's Fair park, is now more likely to pop into the minds of modern Knoxvillians when presented the terms "Knoxville" "Train" "Station." Howev